Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Stubborn Strollers (Part One -- Of Luxury)

It's the mega baby gadget, a must have for every Stubborn Dad, and something that will keep you up at night even before your little squawker arrives: The Stroller.

They come in a variety of shapes and sizes, each with their own benefits and detriments.  And even though you know you won't need it for several months, its the one baby gadget that you'll be jumping to get as soon as you find out your wife is pregnant.

To make this simple, we'll cover the luxury strollers ($500 and up) first, then make our way to the mid-priced strollers ($200 to $499), and then the less-expensive models (less than $200).  Each of these categories may take several blogs, but to make this even easier, we'll save umbrella strollers (the tiny ones that are aptly named because they're small and fold up close to the size of a large umbrella) and jogging strollers (you figure that one out for yourself) for another day.  

So.... here we go:  Strollers -- Luxury Behold ($500+)

Before diving in, let's get a high-level (read pictorial) lay of the land first.  There are several "mainstream" strollers that fit into the five-hundred and up category.  They are as follows (this list is not exhaustive, so please let me know if I've left off any that are worth mentioning):

Micralite Toro Stroller - Black

The Mutsy 4 Rider ($549)
Mutsy 4 Rider Light Stroller College Black -

The Rock Star Baby I'Coo Targo ($569)
I'Coo Targo Stroller & Pram - Houndstooth

The Maclaren Grand Tour LX ($630)
Maclaren GTLXliteblk Grand Tour LX Lite - Black

The Bugaboo Bee ($650)
Bugaboo BEE Complete Stroller - BLACK

The UPPAbaby Vista ($700)
UPPAbaby VISTA Stroller - Black

Bugaboo Frog Complete Stroller - Black
Orbit G2 Stroller with Stroller Seat - Black

Peg-Perego Skate Stroller System - Black Bubbles 








Bugaboo Cameleon Complete Stroller Base Color: Dark Grey 

Now that's out of the way, let's break 'em down.  And we'll start with the grandaddy of them all:

BUGABOO

No doubt you noticed that Bugaboo has three (count them, three!) top-end strollers in the above list (i.e., the Bee, Frog, and Cameleon). 

That's not by accident.  Bugaboo essentially founded the modern luxury category of strollers back in the early 2000's, releasing the Bugaboo Frog in 2001 and landing it an appearance on the HBO series "Sex and The City" in 2002.  Turning that spark of instant celebrity fame into a huge firestorm was easy for Bugaboo (especially given the benefits of the stroller, as explained below), and since 2002, Bugaboo has only upped the ante with the release of the extremely versatile Cameleon in 2005 and the compact Bee in 2007.  Each of these products has since been followed by a series of inspired limited edition lines -- Denim 007 (2007), Marc Jacobs (2008), Paul Frank (2009), Red Collection (2010), and the newest edition, All Black (June 2010).  

Given it's success, it's no secret that Bugaboo knows how to get attention.  And -- as with any luxury stroller -- Bugaboo's strollers also get their parents lots of attention (wanted or not).  Pushing a luxury stroller is not much different than driving a luxury car -- people think you're either snooty, pompous, rich, lucky, or all of the above.  Despite that, who cares?  These things are worth the dirty looks (even if my wife would disagree)!     

As for the Bugaboo, each stroller is inspired by European engineering principles and designed specifically for versatility and modularity. Max Barenbug is the architectural genius behind the Bugaboo designs.  His dream of the modular Bugaboo stroller started at the Design Academy in Eindhoven in 1994, at which time it was so revolutionary that he and his brother were rejected by stroller manufacturers and forced to start their own company (which has worked out OK, I'd say). 

The beauty of the Bugaboo is really it's simplicity.  Less is really more for this gadget (regardless of the cliche, it's true).  The Frog and Cameleon exemplify this by using a central axis as the core of their designs.  This central axis in practicality allows the handle bars and seat to be reversed, as well as allowing and the stroller to go from four wheels to two with a few quick motions. 

The use of this central axis is not insignificant.  The ability to reverse the handle bars on the Frog and Cameleon (so that the larger wheels are in the front) allows for the device to be navigated over grass, rocks, and other bumpy terrain, while switching the device to two wheels allows for a quick romp (read tug) on the beach. 

All models of the Bugaboo are also novel in that they can be easily broken down to their essential parts:  the super-strong stroller frame (made of aircraft alloy), the suspension wheels, and the seat (or bassinet).  This makes for easy storage using the Bugaboo Transport Bag.

For an overview of how the Bugaboo can be disassembled and used in various configurations, see this video for the Frog; this one for the Cameleon; and this one for the Bee.  

The Bee, the less expensive Bugaboo ($649), doesn't quite have the cache or benefits of the Cameleon or Frog, but it still is a Bugaboo, and therefore has been engineered to perform like one. 

The Bee, for example, does have the Bugaboo trademark suspension wheels, which allow it to be "frog-like" and easily navigate bumpy terrain (and allegedly street curbs).  Nonetheless, with smaller back tires and a lower price, you simply can't expect that the Bee's suspension and handling to be as good as the Frog or Cameleon.  (In other words, don't go pushing the Bee over rocks and expect it to feel like glass.)

The Bee is also smaller than both the Frog and Cameleon, which can be good and bad.  In advertising terms, it is more "nimble" than it's counterparts.  (That said, all Bugaboo's are known for their incredible maneuverability and turning capabilities (i.e., you can spin them 360 degrees with one hand).)  However, because it is smaller, it doesn't possess the large wheels that allow the Frog and Cameleon to go anywhere, including beaches.   

Finally, because the Bee is more compact and designed to be collapsible with the seat intact (as opposed to removing the seat prior to collapsing the frame, as required by the Frog and Cameleon), it doesn't have a reversible handle bar and the seat cannot be reversed (meaning you can't place the child facing you).   

The above are trade-offs, however, that some parents are willing to make when they are looking for a more convenient stroller to plop in and out of the car during quick runs to the grocery store.  Also, although the Bee doesn't have a frame that transforms from a bassinet to a seat like the Cameleon and Frog, the Bee's seat does have the ability to fully recline and, if you want to spring for it, the Bee also supports a "baby cocoon" ($99) for use with infants.

But since we skimmed over it, let's get back to the benefit the Bee has over it's older siblings.  This tipping point for some parents (in addition to the lower price tag) is that the Bee can collapse in one motion without removing the seat as required by the Cameleon and Frog.  This is key, as removing the seat from the Frog and Cameleon can be unwieldy for some parents.

Like its older siblings, the Bee does have the ability to accept optional car seat adapters ($45).  The Bugaboo strollers all accept either the Peg Perego, the Maxi Cosi, and the Graco (with the appropriately matched adapter).  (Word of warning here, the car seat adapters must be removed before collapsing the strollers.)

Finally, the Bee does offer an adjustable handle bar like it's more "luxury" sibling the Cameleon.  If you're a tall dad, you'll love being able to adjust the handle bar to accomodate you're height. 

So what about the Cameleon and Frog?  

Bugaboo Frog Complete Stroller - BlackBugaboo Cameleon Complete Stroller Base Color: Dark Grey

Take a look at these strollers and you may think that the only difference between them is the price tags.  You'd be partially right.  The strollers do look similar and have a lot of similar features: reversible handle bar, reversible seat, large wheels for rough terrain.  Further, each stroller has a seat frame that can adapt from a bassinet (to make the stroller a pram) to a seat (to make the stroller a stroller) and vice versa.  (Note, however, that there is one frame and it can be configured either as a bassinet or seat, which means you won't have both options available at the same time.  This seems to be disadventageous, but in reality you will not need the bassinet and seat on the frame at the same time.)  Another commonality of the Frog and Cameleon is that each stroller's seat can be used separate from the stroller (which is really handy at outdoor events, such as sitting poolside). 

But there are also differences between the models.  Are they enough to justify $200 more for the Cameleon?  I think so (when you're paying over $700 for a stroller, why not get the best?), but you're entitled to your own stubborn opinion.

What are the differences between the Frog and Cameleon, you ask?  OK.  I'll tell you.  But not without asking you these five questions:  (1) Does the ability to change the accent fabrics on the stroller matter?  (2) Does enhanced suspension matter?  (3) Does an adjustable handle bar matter? (4) Do you care if your tires are inflatable versus "run-flat"? (5) Does 1/2 inch in additional height for the stroller matter? 

If you answered "NO" (especially if you answered very emphatically), then stop reading, click the link, and buy the Frog:   

But if you answered yes to any of those questions, then you may want to consider whether you should invest a few extra dollars (to be exact, 200) and buy the Cameleon. 













As noted above, the big differences between the Cameleon and the Frog are as follows:

(1) You can purchase tailored fabric in a host of colors to accessorize the Cameleon; you cannot with the Frog. The Cameleon comes with a base fabric (blue, grey, brown, etc.), which cannot be customized once chosen.  However, tailored fabric for the canopy, seat back, and bib on the bassinet may be purchased in various colors and combinations for $99 each. 

This, while it seems trivial, is actually a key feature for the Cameleon.  Just imagine, you have your first child.  You buy a Cameleon in dark grey.  Then you buy tailored fabric to add to the stroller for use with said child -- let's say it's blue, because he's a boy.  Then comes child two, a girl.  Guess what?  You don't have to buy a new stroller.  All you need to do is replace the tailored fabric with pink or yellow, or some other color suitable for a girl other than blue.  Plus, the new tailored fabric gives your stroller that "like new" quality with only a $99 investment.  You simply can't do that with the Frog. 

(2)  The Cameleon has enhanced suspension that allows the ride to be customized based on the weight of the child.  In practicality, most parents will forget that this option exists and leave it on the "softest" suspension through the life of the stroller.  However, stubborn dads like me will use this feature, and will change suspension, going from soft to stiff, as my child grows.  Having the soft suspension available for use with the bassinet does make a difference.    

(3) The Cameleon has adjustable handle bars.  This one's self explanatory.

(4) Here's a big one: the Frog has inflatable tires and comes with a pump for the inevitable day that the tire either gets a hole or goes flat because of age.  The Cameleon, on the other hand, has foam-filled tires that never go flat.  Never going flat verus going flat is a big difference.  If you can make an argument -- any argument -- that the air tires are better, be my guess.  But I just don't see it.  (Note:  Look for the Frog to come with foam-filled tires at some point in the future -- they are just too good not to be used.  That said, the Frog at this point is still sold with air tires.)

(5) The Cameleon is about a half-inch taller than the Frog.  This may also seem trivial, but that inch may allow your child to sit at the dinner table in the stroller versus a high-chair.   

So, you've probably figured out that I like Bugaboo strollers, and in particular I like the Cameleon.  Despite their well-design and function, however, they have their downsides.

First, they're pricey:  paying $1,000 for a stroller is hard to justify when there are much, much, much cheaper models on the market. 

Second, except for the Bee, the requirement that the seat must be removed prior to collapsing the stroller makes it cumbersome.  This isn't so much of a problem if the stroller is not collapsed often, but if you are prone to take it out for errands in a car, then this process of removing and reinserting the seat can be a pain.

Third, the catch that keeps the frame in its collapsed position also makes the Frog and Cameleon difficult to open.  This is complicated by the fact that the person opening the stroller must know exactly what they're doing to keep from cracking their shin each time they attempt to use the stroller.  Getting it right only comes with practice -- something some parents are not willing to do.  If you're one of those parents, get the Bee, or simply don't get a Bugaboo.     

So there you have it, a run down on the Bugaboo luxury strollers.  We'll save the others for future posts (as well as my recommendation in this category), but for now, what are your thoughts?  Do you like or dislike the Bugaboo strollers?  Are you one of those strange folks that has never, and will never, want a Bugaboo?  Why or why not? 

We Stubborn Dads want to know.

Compare and buy the Bugaboo or other strollers at Amazon: